SAN FRANCISCO,. A federal appeals court in San Francisco yesterday rejected the Trump administration’s renewed bid to dismiss a lawsuit by young activists who say the US government is ignoring the perils of climate change.
By a 3-0 vote, the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals said the government fell short of the “high bar” needed to dismiss the Oregon case, originally brought in 2015 against the administration of President Barack Obama.
Twenty-one children and young adults, ages 11 to 22, accused federal officials and oil industry executives of violating their due process rights by knowing for decades that carbon pollution poisons the environment, but doing nothing about it.
The government contended that letting the case proceed would be too burdensome, unconstitutionally pit the courts against the executive branch, and require improper “agency decision-making” by forcing officials to answer questions about climate change.
But the appeals court said the issues raised “are better addressed through the ordinary course of litigation.”
A trial is scheduled for October 29 in the federal court in Eugene, Oregon.
President Donald Trump’s administration also has asked the US Supreme Court to dismiss the lawsuit or put it on hold, and is awaiting a ruling. Its earlier bid to end the lawsuit failed in March.
A spokesman for the US Department of Justice declined to comment.
The activists are seeking various environmental remedies.
Julia Olson, one of their lawyers, said in a phone interview, “The 9th Circuit sees that this case needs to go to trial with a full factual record on the young plaintiffs’ harms, their constitutional rights and climate science.”
The case is US et al v US District Court for the District of Oregon, Eugene, 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals. No. 18-71928.